Best Practices: A New Risk-Reward Calculus For Voluntary Carbon Credit Utilization
Access this research
Access all Corporate Energy Leaders content with a strategic subscription or buy this single report
Need help or have a question about this report? Contact us for assistance
Executive Summary
The voluntary carbon market (VCM) is experiencing a turbulent 2023, after a period of significant growth in 2021 and 2022. The market ecosystem has encountered significant stakeholder backlash, levied at participants operating at all stages of the carbon credit life cycle, from project developers to end-purchasers. A carbon credit theoretically represents a single tonne of emissions mitigation funded voluntarily; however, systemic volatility has led to widespread doubts that this concept has a basis in reality, creating market-wide hesitation about whether firms should offset at all – and if so, how they should do so, to avoid potential reputational damage. This report can be used by executives seeking to upgrade their carbon offsetting strategies to mitigate reputational risk while contributing to global emissions mitigation.The carbon credit market has suffered recent reputational setbacks
Firms must better manage reputational risk as carbon market perceptions shift
Understanding the new carbon market risk-reward calculus
Decarbonization use cases vary in the new risk-reward calculus
Risk in offset strategies can be mitigated through transparency
Carbon credit rating agencies bring clarity to the market
De-risking carbon offset strategies through disclosures
Figure 2. Traditional carbon credit generation processes under fire in 2023
Figure 3. Carbon credit taxonomy
Figure 4. Carbon credit corporate perceptions in 2023
Figure 5. Carbon offset use cases
About the Authors
Connor Taylor
Principal Analyst
Connor is a Principal Analyst at Verdantix. He focuses on delivering research to help senior executives navigate decarbonization decision-making and build effective strategies...
View Profile
Ryan Skinner
Research Director
Ryan is a Research Director at Verdantix, where he leads a team of analysts delivering research, data and advisory services that help clients navigate the fast-evolving landsc...
View ProfileOther related content
Industrial firms around the world are being hammered by operational dislocations and disruptions. Labour shortages, supply chain chokepoints, fast-changing import tariffs, rapid sh...
Upcoming / 25 March, 2026
Energy price volatility, grid instability and geopolitical risk are exposing how vulnerable many organisations’ energy strategies really are. Energy, procurement, operations and su...
Upcoming / 12 March, 2026
For corporate energy leaders, political risk has become one of the hardest variables to price into clean energy strategy, with long-dated power contracts and fixed decarbonization ...
26 January, 2026
Utilities are facing unprecedented grid constraints and long DER connection backlogs, driven by rapid growth in solar, EVs, and storage. Traditional systems alone struggle to provi...
10 February, 2026
Episode 29 The Chief Sustainability Officer (CSO) role has undergone a radical evolution. Once focused primarily on voluntary reporting, policy formation and goal-setting, today’s ...
04 December, 2025
Episode 28 Climate change is not about 2050 – it’s a present-day business reality. From heatwaves changing travel patterns, floods shutting down hotels and transport hubs, and wi...
10 November, 2025